Carnegie Pizza | Nationwide Shipping skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Excelente pizza y mejor atencion!!! Hablan español.
Felipe Lanari Zubiaur via google.com - Oct 21, 2021
Was in NYC for work and decided to go here cause it seemed to have good reviews. The place itself is nice and updated. There are a few tables inside and places to stand and eat, and they have outdoor seating as well. I got their margherita slice and it was quite good. The crust was crispy and the flavor of the sauce and cheese wa ... read more
Harshnil Patel via google.com - Oct 21, 2021
Great selection of New York pizzas that taste amazing!
Alvaro Huaman via google.com - Oct 18, 2021
Best pizza ever. Stopped here on my last day and had to take 3 pieces to go!! The crust is nice and
Best pizza ever. Stopped here on my last day and had to take 3 pieces to go!! The crust is nice and crispy, the sauce is perfect!
Sandra V. via yelp.com - Oct 17, 2021
Great service and very convenient location! Lots of flavor options. Pizza looks great too!
Great service and very convenient location! Lots of flavor options. Pizza looks great too!
Montserrat P. via yelp.com - Oct 17, 2021
Amazing pizza, had a hard time deciding what to get with all the choices. Highly recommend.
Daniel Wells via google.com - Oct 16, 2021
Incredible!! Garlic Knots are my fav.
Brett Wolfe via google.com - Oct 16, 2021
Delish pizza by the slice ... read more
Ted Casey via google.com - Oct 16, 2021
Out of towners staying next door at Hampton-- we walked by this place several days in a row and it s
Out of towners staying next door at Hampton-- we walked by this place several days in a row and it smelled so good. We finally stop in. Grab a slice of pizza and some garlic knots. So so so good. Slices are large. Owner (?) and employees are friendly. Wonderful NY pizza ... read more
C N. via yelp.com - Oct 16, 2021
Just off Times Square but not too busy. Great selection of fresh pizza by the slice. Delicious, slightly sweet crisp crust.
Dom A via google.com - Oct 15, 2021
Best pizza near timesquare ... read more
Yair Alberto Castillo J via google.com - Oct 14, 2021
Very fast service and bilingual workers, very good and convenient. Spinach mushroom pizza super tast
Very fast service and bilingual workers, very good and convenient. Spinach mushroom pizza super tasty and well baked to excellent temperature.
Da A. via yelp.com - Oct 14, 2021
Good pizza!! Had a few places around the area and this was the best. Better than Joe's for sure. For
Good pizza!! Had a few places around the area and this was the best. Better than Joe's for sure. For a to go type of place and the price you can't get better. Thoroughly enjoyed :) ... read more
Jessica B. via yelp.com - Oct 11, 2021
Walking through Times Square and stumbled upon this pizza joint. They sell several pizzas by the sli
Walking through Times Square and stumbled upon this pizza joint. They sell several pizzas by the slice. Definitely the Ny pizza I was looking for ... read more
Miguel R. via yelp.com - Oct 8, 2021
No joke fantastic food. Not greasy, very tasty, spicy pepperoni was awesome. Will be a stop if I ev
No joke fantastic food. Not greasy, very tasty, spicy pepperoni was awesome. Will be a stop if I ever am in town.
Dustin J Kincaid via facebook.com - Oct 7, 2021
Service is excellent. Crust of pizza is amazing. But the pizza tomato sauce is too sweet.
Sharon D. Kenny via google.com - Oct 6, 2021
Amazing service and very clean establishment! Pizza taste delicious!
Kaleigh O via google.com - Oct 6, 2021
Delicious pizza and fast service!
Delicious pizza and fast service!
Kayte Exhibit A Volz via facebook.com - Oct 6, 2021
The BEST PIZZA IN TIME SQUARE!! Finally real pizza don't waste your time going To Joe's hype isn't r
The BEST PIZZA IN TIME SQUARE!! Finally real pizza don't waste your time going To Joe's hype isn't real! From a New Yorker trust me and come here . Clean and delicious great owner ... read more
Laura M. via yelp.com - Sep 28, 2021
Great pizza at a decent price. Workers are cool. The place inside is noisy and not too big, while outside is also noisy and the street is not all that nice.
Javier Urizar via google.com - Sep 27, 2021
The pizza was so good I got barbecue chicken ... read more
Dr Corniel via google.com - Sep 26, 2021
I was walking by and saw a lot of people inside cause it’s by my hotel,and I decided to give it a try later that night…wasn’t disappointed cause the slice that I tried was good.
Manouchka Auguste via google.com - Sep 26, 2021
todas las pizzas están deli
todas las pizzas están deli ... read more
Celina Paredes via facebook.com - Sep 25, 2021
una 💣!!
Andres Gonzalez via google.com - Sep 23, 2021
Good pizza, fast and tasty
Good pizza, fast and tasty ... read more
Anastasia Postoev via facebook.com - Sep 21, 2021
Great! Was my first time, all is good. Patio is good but too noisy from near by vents.
Anastasia Postoev via google.com - Sep 21, 2021
Best pizza place in the area... I work nearby and always get the margherita slice ... read more
Michael Salem via google.com - Sep 20, 2021
The best pizza and great Service the guys are amazing!
The best pizza and great Service the guys are amazing!
Maricela Maravilla-Arguelles via facebook.com - Sep 20, 2021
(Translated by Google) Excellent (Original) Excelente ... read more
Karen Martinez Bloemer via google.com - Sep 19, 2021
Had a late night stop there. Very nice and friendly staff. Quick service. Good food. Will return again on future trips to the city.
David Gallahar via google.com - Sep 19, 2021
best selection of pizzas late at night in Times Square
best selection of pizzas late at night in Times Square ... read more
Hermin Sanchez via facebook.com - Sep 18, 2021
Great pizza just like Italy
Great pizza just like Italy ... read more
Jackie Isidro Maravilla via facebook.com - Sep 17, 2021
AMAZING ... read more
Heather Elise via google.com - Sep 16, 2021
Amazing pizza The flavors come through really well. Slices are very generous as one could be a meal. The dough is light and airy, not heavy at all. Dining in person is ideal, but can order to have shipped, makes well at home. Pizza can be frozen to enjoy later. Wonderful pizza spot in New York City 😋 ... read more
Rosemary (nycstylecannoli) via google.com - Sep 15, 2021
(Translated by Google) Excellent service and pizza (Original) Excelente servicio y pizza ... read more
Miguel Ullloa via google.com - Sep 15, 2021
(Translated by Google) Excellent attention and flavor! (Original) Excelente atención y sabor!
Nicol Coccio Muñoz via google.com - Sep 15, 2021
Pizza was good!! Service was friendly and they have salads! We sat outside and watched the world pass by. The subway entrance at Times Square is across the street and makes for an easy meal before jumping on the subway.
Jennifer Bronson Warren via google.com - Sep 15, 2021
Delicious giant slice of pizza. Need a vaccination card to eat inside like all places now in New York. It's affordable and good. Heated up when you order it.
Meg Peterson via google.com - Sep 15, 2021
Absolutely delicious!!!
Will Monroe via google.com - Sep 13, 2021
We stopped for Lunch as we were wander around the time square area. Excellent garlic knots, never had garlic knots this good!!! Had pepperoni and a veggie slice as well. Excellent pizza, with lots of diverse choices. Great drink options as well. Friendly staff, very clean!
Chris Rosenquist via google.com - Sep 9, 2021
They baked our pizzas after ordering, so they were fresh and delicious.
Risa K via google.com - Sep 7, 2021
Estuve 6 días en NYC y todos los días comí una rebanada de pizza en diferentes lugares. Carnegie Pizza fue la mejor! El servicio, el lugar y obviamente la pizza estuvieron excelente!!! Cuando venga con mis amigos definitivamente los llevaré ahí!
Alma Garcia via google.com - Sep 7, 2021
Great place for pizza if your hungry on Broadway!!!
Bobby Fox via google.com - Sep 6, 2021
Had some yummy Sicilian pizza here. They are the thick style of pizza. First day, I got one slice and it tasted very good. It was about $5 a slice, pricey for NYC but hey, it's Times Square and it was thicker. They have an assortment of all types of pizza (thick and thin) and some salads. The second day, I got a box of Sicilian pizz ... read more
Daniel H via google.com - Sep 5, 2021
Spicy pepperoni pizza pie - is the thing to get here. Carnegie Pizza delivers a delicious pepperoni
Spicy pepperoni pizza pie - is the thing to get here. Carnegie Pizza delivers a delicious pepperoni pizza ! I'm sure it's got a ton of calories but worth it. The pizza itself was good overall - reminded me a little of chain pizzas. Today I read about Nimbus, a "shared use commercial kitchen" that's selling Brooklyn pizza in Manhattan ... read more
Marie S. via yelp.com - Sep 4, 2021
Una maravilla su pan con ajo y excelente atención los recomendaré con todos los latinos que conozca que vayan a ny Mi hija fascinada con las pizzas ... read more
Gaby Escobar via google.com - Aug 29, 2021
Pizza was great and the service was too. Will definitely be going there alot.
Abanoub ASD via google.com - Aug 27, 2021
Pizza is awesome here! Garlic knots are on point. They have a huge variety. Sicilian style is where it's at! Stay away from the pineapple ham pizza. Im not a hater, but they use canned pineapple and it has that canned flavor, ya know? Great place though,do try!
A.D. Watson via google.com - Aug 27, 2021
Delicious pizza ... read more
Jason Armstrong via google.com - Aug 25, 2021
carnegie pizza has the best cheese calzones i've ever had. i'm not a calzone guy; i'm a normal pizza
carnegie pizza has the best cheese calzones i've ever had. i'm not a calzone guy; i'm a normal pizza slice guy. the cheese calzone is the best thing on the menu. trust me the internet guy and get the cheese calzone. it's texture, taste, cheese juices--i have been back 4 times! go ahead and get ur pizza slice but also get a cheese cal ... read more
Mark A. via yelp.com - Aug 25, 2021
great food. friendly employee
great food. friendly employee ... read more
Robert Tillson via facebook.com - Aug 20, 2021
Amazing pizza at low prices!
Beni Vradman via google.com - Aug 20, 2021
I finally found my favorite pizza place. I am not a local in New York so whenever I get the chance to visit I make it a point to venture out into New York City and go to all the nice restaurants that I can see. I tried out Carnegie Pizza after looking at some of their reviews. My review starts here. I really like this pizza place.
K via google.com - Aug 19, 2021
I visited this place THREE times in 4 days...THREE!! This pizza is to die for. Best I have ever had. Hands down. The crust of both the Sicilian style and the regular style is so good. Just enough crisp, the cheese blend is so delicious and the sauce is amazing. Love, love, love this spot. Can't wait to get back to NYC for it!
Sean Kalil via google.com - Aug 18, 2021
muy deliciosas, volveré 😍 ... read more
Alexis Arcaya via google.com - Aug 16, 2021
My only regret is not buying the hooded sweatshirt while I was there. Everything was great.
Vincent Maroun via google.com - Aug 16, 2021
פיצה מעולה ממוקמת ליד הכיכר הטיים. טעימה ברמות! ממש מזכירה פיצות איכותיות.. ממלית במיוחד על הפיצה ההפוכה (עם הרסק למעלה גבינה למטה) והפיצה עם הפטריות ותרד. הלחם שום אששש!
אנחל חי ארביב via google.com - Aug 16, 2021
Late night quick dinner. Dropped in after a long commute to NYC. The place is clean, well lit, bustl
Late night quick dinner. Dropped in after a long commute to NYC. The place is clean, well lit, bustling with customers. It has inside and outside(sidewalk) seating. Friendly servers, fair prices. But, oh, the pizza! Many different choices, buy the slice or the pie. Good, good, so, good. Will go again to taste a different selection: B ... read more
Frmme via tripadvisor.com - Aug 13, 2021
Literalmente la Mejor pizza de NY, 1000% recomendada, full atencion y lo mejor la calidad de las pi
Literalmente la Mejor pizza de NY, 1000% recomendada, full atencion y lo mejor la calidad de las pizzas y la gran variedad!!! Amé el pan de ajo y la pizza de berenjena OMG!! Precios de acuerdo a la calidad!! 😋😋 ... read more
Esoj Zenitram Zurc via facebook.com - Aug 11, 2021
Best pizza! We absolutely loved it! Place is clean, and good price for absolutely best slice ... read more
Matthew Henehan via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
This place was really close to my hotel on Times Square. Had their pizza a couple of times. The staf
This place was really close to my hotel on Times Square. Had their pizza a couple of times. The staff has a great attitude. Pizza was generally good. Can’t say the best but certainly good.
ASALEHK via tripadvisor.com - Aug 11, 2021
I’ve just had some pizzas now. So delicious!!👍The dough is so crispy and chewy, and I love it so much😍 I’ll definitely come here to eat again❤️ ... read more
Sumin Song via google.com - Aug 9, 2021
There is nothing much to say, Best pizza ever here in US! We love it!
B. C. via google.com - Aug 9, 2021
Very tasty. Excellent service. Just a little expensive because of the location.
Joan Manuel Cuadrado García via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
Great place, next door to the Hampton Inn. Flew in, checked in and got a slice here. First New York
Great place, next door to the Hampton Inn. Flew in, checked in and got a slice here. First New York pizza and it was super good. Looking forward to comparing over the weekend! Super nice guys too ... read more
Derek P via tripadvisor.com - Aug 6, 2021
Carnegie pizza has a solid square pizza, bottom was crispy, dough was light, and the toppings and ch
Carnegie pizza has a solid square pizza, bottom was crispy, dough was light, and the toppings and cheese were good.
Ashwinee P. via yelp.com - Aug 4, 2021
We just got here and google mapped pizza. Carnegie popped up near by with good reviews. We dined in. It was DELICIOUS. Plus they are on Gold Belly. Works for me. One slice was fulfilling.
Shantonia Bullard via google.com - Aug 3, 2021
Nice fresh pizza and very clean place.
Incaball pe via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing pizza before! The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed. The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the littl ... read more
Carol Alexander via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Best pizza in town!! Fresh ingredients, crunchy base, served hot, great topping choices and honest prices. Could eat here every night I stay in NYC and not regret it!!
Linde Kampers via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza before! The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed. The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the little sl ... read more
Carol M. via yelp.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza before! The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed. The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the little sl ... read more
Jiggybaby360 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing piz
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing pizza before! Love this place!
Carolina Cristina via facebook.com - Jul 30, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire