Reviews

Best peperoni Pizza at Times Square ... read more

Tobias Stadler via google.com - May 23, 2022

Great pizza! Best I’ve had in New York as to date. Fluffy and garlicky crust with great cheese and toppings, quick service, and a couple outdoor tables to sit. 100% Recommended ... read more

Jacob Botnick via google.com - May 22, 2022

I liked this pizza better than Joe's ... read more

William Elliott via google.com - May 22, 2022

Muy grasosa pero rica. Very greasy and unhealthy but delicious. Great place for dinner if you need to gain a few pounds. Love Carnegie pizza 😍 ... read more

Joseph Strohmeyer via google.com - May 21, 2022

The best pizza around Times Square, a must of you are visiting NY ... read more

Gonzalo Gomez via google.com - May 20, 2022

Fantastic Pizza! Was in the area on business for the week and Carnegie Pizza quickly became my go to spot to grab a quick slice (or two in my case). Every time the pizza was perfect and exactly what I was craving. If you are in the area and you aren't getting Carnegie Pizza, you are definitely missing out!

Tim Ostrom via google.com - May 19, 2022

Had a slice of pepperoni. It was great. They do have an outside seating area that is covered and blocked from the elements. Close to Times Square but off the beaten path enough not to be too crazy. They have some great pictures on the walls to check out while you’re wearing your pizza. They also have a number of drinks available ... read more

Matt Olson via google.com - May 19, 2022

Non-descript appearance and excellent pizza. If you read this review, stop thinking it over and go t

Non-descript appearance and excellent pizza. If you read this review, stop thinking it over and go there. You won't be disappointed.

J J. via yelp.com - May 19, 2022

Did this for the free slice ... read more

Krishak Oberoi via google.com - May 18, 2022

Excellent restaurant, great service

Excellent restaurant, great service ... read more

Vincent M. via yelp.com - May 17, 2022

Lecker ❤️❤️❤️❤️🥰 ... read more

gh jdjs via google.com - May 16, 2022

We got pizza here our first night and it was great. But after walking by multiple times and not getting the garlic knots... We grabbed a snack and sooo glad we did! Great pizza great garlic knots! It's all heated up served hot just how you want it! They even have a deep dish if that fits your fancy! Definitely a must if you want some ... read more

Dan S. via google.com - May 15, 2022

Awesome pizza! Great smells!

Pratik Bhatter via google.com - May 15, 2022

Lots of options and great location for a quick dinner before a show ... read more

Rachel Pampel via google.com - May 14, 2022

Awesome pizza. Friendly service 😊 ... read more

Nathan Keating via google.com - May 13, 2022

Amazing place and Taste! Generous Slice ... read more

Braulio Gomes via google.com - May 13, 2022

Great PIZZA

The pizza is delicious and the service was great!!! The restaurant was clean also! Highly recommended!

RocB2000 via tripadvisor.com - May 13, 2022

Excellent! Pizza très bonnes et prix raisonnable ... read more

William Bleuse via google.com - May 12, 2022

perfect after broadway show hot slice! and the staff is super friendly and helpful. would come again

perfect after broadway show hot slice! and the staff is super friendly and helpful. would come again in a heartbeat.

Jessy A. via yelp.com - May 12, 2022

I would say best buck to food in dollar slice range ! Nothing beats this place when you want to grab and go slice ! The variety of options and choices for everyone is just wonderful ! Garlic knots are not to missed, as well as the upside down pizza ... read more

Jay Donda via google.com - May 11, 2022

Très bonnes pizza New Yorkaises, prix très abordables.

Maël Mountassir via google.com - May 10, 2022

Great place come here all the time ... read more

Barq via google.com - May 10, 2022

This little gem was located near our hotel and I had seen it on youtube and instagram, so why not? T

This little gem was located near our hotel and I had seen it on youtube and instagram, so why not? The place is clean but small. The staff is nice. The food was pretty cheap and fresh. The pizzas were quite good. The garlic knot not my favorite as it wasn't soft and more hard to bite into. Overall, a good fast bite, especially late n ... read more

Natasha S. via yelp.com - May 9, 2022

New York pizza at it's best. Excellent service to boost!

L Mailloux via google.com - May 7, 2022

Good food and kind staff . The pizza is very tasty. I would recommend you to come here. One only problem is that there is little space.

Alam Sayeed via google.com - May 7, 2022

Super tasty ... read more

Katie McCarty via google.com - May 7, 2022

This some goodazz pizza!!! Crust is so perfect!! Hell yeah I'm going back!!

Shelene (Sweety) via google.com - May 7, 2022

For being as close to times square as it is, I was pleasantly surprised how legit Carnegie Pizza was

For being as close to times square as it is, I was pleasantly surprised how legit Carnegie Pizza was. Would I go out of my way to eat here given all the amazing pizza options in NY, no. But grabbing a bite before a broadway show, this hit the spot. The line moved quickly / basically no wait and we were even able to snag a table. Defi ... read more

Flora H. via yelp.com - May 7, 2022

Amazing pizza! Good vibes :) if you're looking for good pizza then come here for it!

Sam L. via yelp.com - May 7, 2022

Les meilleures parts de pizzas 😍 ... read more

Marine L via google.com - May 6, 2022

Two weeks ago I first tried the pizza at Carnegie Pizza. I ordered the veggie: onion, pepper, and mushroom Sicilian slice, while my partner ordered a chicken buffalo slice, an eggplant Sicilian slice to share and some garlic knots to share as well. Not gonna lie here this is probably the best Sicilian slice I've ever had. The crust ... read more

Jireh Garcia via google.com - May 6, 2022

Nice pizza, very clean place ! Pizza are oily but delicious !

Pauline Lievin via google.com - May 5, 2022

Best pizza ever!!! Get spicy salami ... read more

Miami Extreme via google.com - Apr 27, 2022

Really good pizza. A bit pricey.

C.Michael Hoff via google.com - Apr 25, 2022

La mejor pizza de Times Square ... read more

Javier Casquero Sánchez via google.com - Apr 25, 2022

Good slices, friendly people even if busy.

Bjarke Frost Nielsen via google.com - Apr 24, 2022

Just incredible. Great pizza ... read more

Bill Wawro via google.com - Apr 22, 2022

Best pizza in town ... read more

Sudol via google.com - Apr 21, 2022

Really good pizza, good price and fast!

Íris Brito via google.com - Apr 20, 2022

YOU WILL LOVE THIS PIZZA!

Our family of four traveled to NY for six days on April. I think that about four days we ate this pizza, it's so delicious! Don't miss to try it. Everything looks clean, and tastes good!

WCP1978 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 19, 2022

Very good Food was great doing this for the free slice and need to use 85 characters to post it

Very good Food was great doing this for the free slice and need to use 85 characters to post it ... read more

Beckett B. via yelp.com - Apr 19, 2022

🗽🍕For my first time having NY style pizza this sure sets a standard. Pizza was crispy enough and flavorful💥🔥. Great place for a quick bite. Worth checking out if you’re in the time square area‼️ ... read more

Alberto Perez via google.com - Apr 16, 2022

Best pizza on the block! We love it here 10/10 Love the hard working men there !! They are nice

Best pizza on the block! We love it here 10/10 Love the hard working men there !! They are nice ... read more

Diana N. via yelp.com - Apr 16, 2022

Must to do in NY ... read more

Diego Bonilla via google.com - Apr 15, 2022

Son demasiado buenas, me encanta. Si vienen a Ny deben de visitar este lugar. 🥰👌🏼 ... read more

Vianny Melo moquete via google.com - Apr 15, 2022

Buona la pepperoni pizza, discreta la chicken. Posizione eccellente, gusto deciso e impasto croccante ... read more

Riccardo Capitani via google.com - Apr 13, 2022

So delicious! Fast, Hot, well cooked 👌 ... read more

Richard A. Charlemagne via google.com - Apr 12, 2022

Fantastica

Una pizza da cinque stelle!!…Trovata per caso ma cavoli che pizza!!…Assolutamente consigliata..prezzi nella norma ... read more

Ryk182 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 11, 2022

Good pizza. Good price. Wish there was a restroom; however, the workers were very helpful directing

Good pizza. Good price. Wish there was a restroom; however, the workers were very helpful directing us to a restroom right down the street.

Caroline G. via yelp.com - Apr 11, 2022

Garlic knots!! Garlic knots!! And don't forget the sauce! Family loved the pizza!. : ) ... read more

Demi via google.com - Apr 10, 2022

Excellent. Some of the best thin crust pizza I have ever had.

David Manka via google.com - Apr 9, 2022

A surprise favorite! We went there 4 times!!!!! The garlic knots are the best and wonderful kind ser

A surprise favorite! We went there 4 times!!!!! The garlic knots are the best and wonderful kind service ... read more

Kristy S. via yelp.com - Apr 9, 2022

Pizza slices were up to the mark. Not at all greasy. Super fresh and the staff is really helpful

Pizza slices were up to the mark. Not at all greasy. Super fresh and the staff is really helpful ... read more

Meet P. via yelp.com - Apr 9, 2022

Not a local, so when you see two cops walk out with satisfied faces and rubbing their stomach, you K

Not a local, so when you see two cops walk out with satisfied faces and rubbing their stomach, you KNOW it's good pizza. And they didn't disappoint.

Docta P. via yelp.com - Apr 8, 2022

Delicious slices! Perfect crust and not too greasy. It was right around the corner from our show. They have a few tables and a stand up bar to eat at.

Troy Powell via google.com - Apr 7, 2022

Great pizza. Friendly service.

Kian Alavy via google.com - Apr 6, 2022

Absolutely amazing pizza! For my first trip to NY it was the best pizza I’ve ever had and am definitely coming back for seconds!

Bradley W via google.com - Apr 6, 2022

The pizza was tasty and because of regular turnover, it was fresher. NJ pizza still beats it. It's definitely overpriced per slice, but it's a tourist trap area.

AJ via google.com - Apr 5, 2022

During my stay in NYC/Times Square, I tried pizza at 6 pizza places. Carnegie Pizza is the best, HAN

During my stay in NYC/Times Square, I tried pizza at 6 pizza places. Carnegie Pizza is the best, HANDS DOWN! The pizza, garlic knots, and dipping sauce was the best NYC has to offer! The atmosphere and customer service were also pretty awesome. I can't wait to visit again and eat here again.

Lindsey S. via yelp.com - Apr 4, 2022

Love the spicy peperoni ... read more

Christian Andres Palencia Hernandez via google.com - Apr 2, 2022

Customer service was A1 and the pizza was delicious ... read more

El Boogie via google.com - Apr 1, 2022

Now...I may get a bit controversial here. Iam fresh off a trip to Chicago. This was some great pizza. Crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and friendly staff. Conveniently located near times square and my hotel. I had the spicy pepperoni and the margherita slices. I left happy and full!

SVG Commercial Cleaning LLC via google.com - Apr 1, 2022

Best pizza around Times Square, fresh and delicious and the place is super clean ! Try it you be bac

Best pizza around Times Square, fresh and delicious and the place is super clean ! Try it you be back for more !

Jeanette S. via yelp.com - Mar 31, 2022

Great pizza!!!

jason hall via google.com - Mar 30, 2022

De todas las pizzas que comí en New York esta fue la mejor. Además, la atención fue excelente!! Solo acotaría que para mi gusto estaban un poquito pasadas de sal. Imperdible!!

Andres Aliaga (ErancO) via google.com - Mar 30, 2022

The best pizza I have eaten in a long time. They have unique topping combinations. I liked the veggie medley and egg plant Parmesan pizzas.

Binny Samuel via google.com - Mar 28, 2022

Service is fast and the pizza is very very good. The best I’ve tried in NYC so far. The eggplant pizza had a bit too much garlic for my taste but I’m sure others might like that. Don’t eat it if you’re planning to go on a date after 😂 ... read more

Siavoush Fallahi via google.com - Mar 27, 2022

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Subscribe to our NEWSLETTER