Reviews

Best pizza in the city they know how to stack the cheese thick, crisp the crispy crust till it’s well done and just falls apart in your mouth the sauce is freaking amazing I don’t know if they can mess up perfect everytime ... read more

Jerald Hagadorn via google.com - May 11, 2021

Excelente lugar, excelente pizza. Los pisos brillan. Los precios son buenos. Excelente clientela, recomendables. Se puede comer en el lugar.

Mariano San Martin via google.com - May 10, 2021

The pizza was 😋 absolutely delicious!!! Clean, fast table service!! Fresh!! I will return for my Hawaiian slice!!

Sharon Parson via google.com - Apr 28, 2021

The place smells AMAZING as soon as you open the door. The pizza is absolutely delicious. I ordered from here based on a combination of proximity to hotel and Google reviews and I'm thrilled. The pizza was ready sooner than expected, the staff was friendly and anticipated my needs by pre-packing plenty of plates and napkins for me. S ... read more

Amanda Banta via google.com - Apr 22, 2021

NOT A FAKE REVIEW: THIS PLACE IS FREAKING AMAZING!!! As God is my witness! Everyone must come and try their pizza! I have eaten a lot of pizza in NYC just check my reviews! This place I put at the same level as Joe's pizza! JUST LOOK AG MY PICTURES! Seriously dude! The pizza has fresh mozzarella cheese! Spicy crispy pepperoni! Th ... read more

Kevin H via google.com - Apr 16, 2021

We just got into town and walked to Times Square and we were very hungry. Ran into this lil pizza pl

We just got into town and walked to Times Square and we were very hungry. Ran into this lil pizza place and all the pizza looked so good. The staff was super friendly and the pepperoni was great. My wife got the Margarita pizza slice and it was on point. I recommend it if you want a quick meal.

HJ379 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 16, 2021

NOT A FAKE REVIEW: THIS PLACE IS FREAKING AMAZING!!! As God is my witness! Everyone must come and tr

Kevin H. via yelp.com - Apr 16, 2021

Stumbled upon this place while heading back to our hotel. What a treat that was, the pizza was crispy and cheesy at the same time! They had so many single slice types of pizza to choose from and they all looked so good it was hard to choose!

Jennifer Martin via google.com - Mar 29, 2021

Very tasty pizza and friendly staff!

Dima via google.com - Mar 29, 2021

Good pizza ... read more

Juan busanet via google.com - Mar 26, 2021

Amazing new place, will visit whenever i'm in NYC! The pizza is amazing especially the margarita and pepperoni slices! Clean and friendly staff. Will be back ... read more

Jessica K via google.com - Mar 26, 2021

Got a Margherita and a Red slice, both were delicious with a crispy crust and delicious sauce and toppings. The staff were friendly and the shop is kept very clean. One of my new favorite pizza places! I'll definitely be back.

Jonathan Zisser via google.com - Mar 26, 2021

Amazing new place, will visit whenever i'm in NYC! The pizza is amazing especially the margarita and

Amazing new place, will visit whenever i'm in NYC! The pizza is amazing especially the margarita and pepperoni slices! Clean and friendly staff. Will be back!

Jess K. via yelp.com - Mar 25, 2021

Never have I ever enjoyed such a ridiculous volume of greasy pepperoni on a thick crust. Enjoy this stop...steps from the Aladdin theater.

Brandon Klingensmith via google.com - Mar 19, 2021

The Margarita and Mushroom & Spinach pizza were tasty. The place was clean and servers were nice.

Leonardo Torres via google.com - Mar 12, 2021

This place is amazing, it refreshing to see such great place in the city, been going here for couple of weeks now, pizza is amazing, place is super clean and the staff is very friendly. Highly recommend!!

Valdrin Ademaj via google.com - Mar 5, 2021

Delicious traditional NY pizza . Go here! Run by an amazing family and pizza is delicious!!!

Mel Peters via google.com - Mar 5, 2021

Good pizza ... read more

Tommy Modula via google.com - Jan 2, 2021

First time in New York and the best Pizza! Freshly hand made!

Leo Dagne via google.com - Jan 2, 2021

Great pizza with a wonderful sauce although not as hot as you would hope on arrival. The garlic knot

Great pizza with a wonderful sauce although not as hot as you would hope on arrival. The garlic knots were a little dry but the garlic and basil on them saved it. I would order from here again because that pizza sauce was tasty!

Jillian T. via yelp.com - Dec 22, 2020

Great new slice shop. Super clean and fresh. Friendly staff and really nice owner. See photos for the quality of this place ... read more

Jeff Gebott via google.com - Dec 2, 2020

I HAVEN'T LEFT MY HOUSE IN 3 MONTHS BUT WHEN I HEARD ABOUT THIS PLACE I HAD TO GET OUT OF HIDING. HANDS DOWN THE BEST PIZZA IN THE CITY TOTALLY WORTH IT. ALSO NICEST/CLEANEST PIZZERIA I'VE EVER BEEN TOO ... read more

Brandon Rubinshtein via google.com - Dec 2, 2020

Pizza is great Keep the place clean and sanitized ... read more

MYX STUDIOS via google.com - Dec 2, 2020

Very good pizza!!! Loved the atmosphere, very clean and took great COVID precautions. Overall great

Very good pizza!!! Loved the atmosphere, very clean and took great COVID precautions. Overall great eats!

Andres S. via yelp.com - Nov 28, 2020

I have to admit, Carnegie Pizza was really phenomenal. Pleasant ambience. Every thing I've tried so

I have to admit, Carnegie Pizza was really phenomenal. Pleasant ambience. Every thing I've tried so far is great. Staff are very lovely and service is very swift. Carnegie Pizza is by far the best of the best in this area.

Patricia W. via yelp.com - Nov 15, 2020

You can find your classic New York slice here. Good cheese to sauce to crust to oil ratio. Fresh ing

You can find your classic New York slice here. Good cheese to sauce to crust to oil ratio. Fresh ingredients, fast and friendly service, clean space. I'll be back to try the other slices.

Mi Rae C. via yelp.com - Nov 3, 2020

Love the crispy crust, the rich flavors and variety! The Owner and staff are friendly, professional

Love the crispy crust, the rich flavors and variety! The Owner and staff are friendly, professional and the place is kept extremely clean. My favorite place in NYC for pizza so far!

Maria T. via yelp.com - Nov 1, 2020

This shiny new pizza joint has open one block from Times Square and PABT. They have about a dozen pi

This shiny new pizza joint has open one block from Times Square and PABT. They have about a dozen pies, sicilian too and garlic knots. So new the menu is not up. Got me a reqular slice of sausage pizza and it had that New York pizza taste not only was it not oily but had a thin crust too. I be trying the garlic knots next time I pass ... read more

Tom G. via yelp.com - Oct 21, 2020

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Subscribe to our NEWSLETTER