Carnegie Pizza | Nationwide Shipping skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Nice fresh pizza and very clean place.
Incaball pe via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing pizza before! The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed. The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the littl ... read more
Carol Alexander via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Best pizza in town!! Fresh ingredients, crunchy base, served hot, great topping choices and honest prices. Could eat here every night I stay in NYC and not regret it!!
Linde Kampers via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza before! The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed. The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the little sl ... read more
Jiggybaby360 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I've ever had in NYC and I've had some amazing pizza before! The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed. The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the little sl ... read more
Carol M. via yelp.com - Jul 31, 2021
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing piz
Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing pizza before! Love this place!
Carolina Cristina via facebook.com - Jul 30, 2021
Good selection of pizza, things move fast. A little pricey but quite tasty ... read more
Michael Cocco Jr via google.com - Jul 29, 2021
Outstanding! We were looking for really good NY style pizza, and this really hit the spot! Fantastic
Outstanding! We were looking for really good NY style pizza, and this really hit the spot! Fantastic pizza and great service!!! One of the new owners came out to personally check on us. Would highly recommend!!!
Lindsey P. via yelp.com - Jul 29, 2021
Omggg we were in NYC for 8 days and we came here on four of those days. If I could fly my ass over t
Omggg we were in NYC for 8 days and we came here on four of those days. If I could fly my ass over to eat one slice I WOULD. Greetings from Sacramento and y'all NEED to go here.
Jason R. via yelp.com - Jul 29, 2021
Our new find for slices in the Times Square area. We visited based on reviews and were not disappoin
Our new find for slices in the Times Square area. We visited based on reviews and were not disappointed. Typical slices kind of vibe, but nicer than most. Everything we ordered was great (pepperoni slices, sausage slices, their spicy pepperoni Sicilian slice). We are on our first night in the city and could not wait to return to eat ... read more
David T. via yelp.com - Jul 27, 2021
Good choices and tasted delicious!
Good choices and tasted delicious!
Jermal Parham via facebook.com - Jul 26, 2021
pizza is ready to eat. The establishment was clean.
pizza is ready to eat. The establishment was clean.
Araceli Payan via facebook.com - Jul 23, 2021
Best slice we had in the city! Great selection, garlic knots tasty, and good prices.
Danton Brown via google.com - Jul 23, 2021
Great!!! Margarita Pizza hit the spot after walkin around Time Square.
Brice Ciener via google.com - Jul 23, 2021
Saw that the spicy pepperoni pizza was recommended. Gave it a try and it was amazing. It was fresh, juicy, crunchy, and the slice was gigantic. Greatly recommend.
Antonio Roman via google.com - Jul 18, 2021
Muy rica la pizza, como me gusta crocante y mucho queso. La atención muy buena. Gracias a los empleados.
Sarita Thombs via google.com - Jul 18, 2021
We are staying at the Hampton Inn and stopped by for a quick bite. Fast and yummy!
GA R via google.com - Jul 16, 2021
I love the pizza here. Especially pepperoni slice.
Keith Watson via google.com - Jul 15, 2021
Our entire group loved Carnegie Pizza! We had just about every combination they offered and whether
Our entire group loved Carnegie Pizza! We had just about every combination they offered and whether it was the cheese options, veggie options, or loaded with meat, everyone in our group of 7 said it was the best meal we had that week. We ate at several places between Ohio and NYC and Carnegie's was the absolute best. The service was ... read more
Regina H. via yelp.com - Jul 15, 2021
I tried this place because it was a catered lunch by my office. OMG. I can't stop thinking of this p
I tried this place because it was a catered lunch by my office. OMG. I can't stop thinking of this place. I loved the Vodka slice, it was sweet, cheesey, with a perfect amount of basil on top. It was amazing. The pepperoni was incredible as well! This place needs to be blasted on a billboard and here is the first step to that! :) Do ... read more
Karly M. via yelp.com - Jul 15, 2021
Such a great find in NYC! A few doors down from our hotel. We found it our first night in town and h
Such a great find in NYC! A few doors down from our hotel. We found it our first night in town and had to have it our last night again!! Everything was delicious and such reasonable prices.
Dawn C. via yelp.com - Jul 14, 2021
Good pizza and very friendly personal 👍🏼
Good pizza and very friendly personal 👍🏼 ... read more
Esther Angélica Alvarez López via facebook.com - Jul 6, 2021
Pizza is delicious and the staff is friendly ... read more
Uncle Danny Cooks via google.com - Jul 3, 2021
Best pizza in NYC. All fresh ingredients, everything prepped and cooked on-site, amazing choices, clean environment, and great staff coupled with the right amount of old-school New York pie makes this a don't-miss, whether you're a local or in from out-of-town!
Greg Laskody via google.com - Jul 1, 2021
Best pizza in NYC. All fresh ingredients, everything prepped and cooked on-site, amazing choices, cl
Best pizza in NYC. All fresh ingredients, everything prepped and cooked on-site, amazing choices, clean environment, and great staff coupled with the right amount of old-school New York pie makes this a don't-miss, whether you're a local or in from out-of-town!
Greg L. via yelp.com - Jul 1, 2021
I wanted the "getting a slice of NYC pizza at a small place" experience. They sell slices everywhere. But that I chose this place was extremely lucky. This is exactly what you want. Simple, cheap, unassuming, delicious. Yet extremely high quality. The margarita was what it should be. A good tomato sauce is made from good (and few) in ... read more
Kazebu Honda via google.com - Jun 30, 2021
Best pizza in Times Square! With so many mediocre pizza places in the area preying on clueless tourists, do yourself a favor and go to Carnegie. All of their food is top notch!
Michael L via google.com - Jun 29, 2021
Best pizza in Times Square! Definitely check it out if you are in the area. I've tried a lot of thei
Best pizza in Times Square! Definitely check it out if you are in the area. I've tried a lot of their slices and have not been disappointed thus far ... read more
Michael L. via yelp.com - Jun 29, 2021
That Spicy Peperoni pizza is just unbeatable ... read more
Alejandro L via google.com - Jun 27, 2021
We love this place. The best pizza in NYC I’ve had so far🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕💯💯💯💯 ... read more
Anthony Johnson via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
(Translated by Google) Satiating is well (Original) Para saciar el hambre está bien ... read more
Katheryn Flores via google.com - Jun 24, 2021
The pizza was great crispy and everything however the there could me more cheese on the pizza and le
The pizza was great crispy and everything however the there could me more cheese on the pizza and less crispy. Other then that it was amazing.
Albert S. via yelp.com - Jun 24, 2021
These guys are the best! Great pizza but also incredible guest relations and they will treat you really nice! Loved it !!!
Rodrigo Palota via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
Amazing pizza, highly recommended to anyone coming to NYC. Staff was great and everything was very clean.
Alon Yemini via google.com - Jun 13, 2021
Best Slice in NY hands Down! End of conversation. The old school pepperoni slice is incredible. A must try if you live in Manhattan. Service is on point. LOCAL HEAT!!
flynn vitale via google.com - Jun 13, 2021
Excelente lugar muy sabrosas y muy limpio ... read more
sergio carrillo via google.com - Jun 12, 2021
Great pizza, glad we made this our first NYC stop!
Randy Smith via google.com - Jun 12, 2021
Great pizza! Glad we made this our first stop!
Great pizza! Glad we made this our first stop!
Randy Smith via facebook.com - Jun 12, 2021
La Mejor Pizza Nos Encanto 100% recomendada ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ ... read more
Karolene Correa via google.com - Jun 12, 2021
Great pizza! Glad we started our trip off here. Tried bbq chicken pizza, Sicilian white pizza, and k
Great pizza! Glad we started our trip off here. Tried bbq chicken pizza, Sicilian white pizza, and knots. If you love garlic, you'll love the knots!
Randy S. via yelp.com - Jun 12, 2021
Just the right place to eat NY pizza . Super clean space, nice people serving freshly made pizza. Co
Just the right place to eat NY pizza . Super clean space, nice people serving freshly made pizza. Conveniently located and not far from action but far enough from the crowds.
Angela B. via yelp.com - Jun 11, 2021
Delicious pizza!
Jason Bakos via google.com - Jun 7, 2021
Good clean atmosphere. Fast service. Awesome pizza 🍕
Good clean atmosphere. Fast service. Awesome pizza 🍕 ... read more
Donella Squire via facebook.com - Jun 6, 2021
Excelente servicio. Excelente valor por el dinero Muy buena relación precio / calidad Tiene muy buena ubicación Las pizzas tienen muy buen sabor y variedad de opciones. El tamaño de las porciones es perfecto! Recomendado. Excelente lugar.
Salvador Calderón A. via google.com - Jun 5, 2021
Recomendado. Muy cerca a Times Square ... read more
Patricia Gutiérrez via google.com - Jun 5, 2021
Pizza was great and you must get the garlic knots! Clean space and friendly staff and yummy food! Th
Pizza was great and you must get the garlic knots! Clean space and friendly staff and yummy food! There's a lot of pizza in NYC, but this one is worth stopping for ... read more
Bruce S. via yelp.com - Jun 5, 2021
Great pizza 🍕🍕🍕 ... read more
jorge ruiz jr via google.com - Jun 4, 2021
This pizza looked amazing. We took it to go to eat in the train! It was really good. My favorite was the eggplant so yummy!!
ROSAS FAM via google.com - Jun 2, 2021
Had 5 slices to go and garlic knots Service was quick and nice. My very favorite was the eggplant pi
Had 5 slices to go and garlic knots Service was quick and nice. My very favorite was the eggplant pizza. It was the bomb! Their garlic knots were very garlicky and delicious I paid $30 ... read more
Yejo R. via yelp.com - Jun 2, 2021
Nice, clean, good price. Great great pizza.
Will Devlin via google.com - May 31, 2021
Amazing pizza. Felt like it was that New York style you crave to find from those lesser than nice joints, but this place was actually super nice. Would 100% go back!
Jameson Bradley via google.com - May 25, 2021
Good slice, glad we stopped in. Staff was super friendly and the food was good. We would def visit t
Good slice, glad we stopped in. Staff was super friendly and the food was good. We would def visit the place again if we make it back.
Shannon T. via yelp.com - May 15, 2021
Best pizza in the city they know how to stack the cheese thick, crisp the crispy crust till it’s well done and just falls apart in your mouth the sauce is freaking amazing I don’t know if they can mess up perfect everytime ... read more
Jerald Hagadorn via google.com - May 11, 2021
This pizza is the best in the city in fact I bet the world they know how to stack the cheese and bak
This pizza is the best in the city in fact I bet the world they know how to stack the cheese and bake the crispy crust till it's well done. The pizza just falls apart in your mouth I can just feel how watery my mouth is getting thinking about it!
Jerald H. via yelp.com - May 11, 2021
Excelente lugar, excelente pizza. Los pisos brillan. Los precios son buenos. Excelente clientela, recomendables. Se puede comer en el lugar.
Mariano San Martin via google.com - May 10, 2021
The pizza was 😋 absolutely delicious!!! Clean, fast table service!! Fresh!! I will return for my Hawaiian slice!!
Sharon Parson via google.com - Apr 28, 2021
The place smells AMAZING as soon as you open the door. The pizza is absolutely delicious. I ordered from here based on a combination of proximity to hotel and Google reviews and I'm thrilled. The pizza was ready sooner than expected, the staff was friendly and anticipated my needs by pre-packing plenty of plates and napkins for me. S ... read more
Amanda Banta via google.com - Apr 22, 2021
NOT A FAKE REVIEW: THIS PLACE IS FREAKING AMAZING!!! As God is my witness! Everyone must come and try their pizza! I have eaten a lot of pizza in NYC just check my reviews! This place I put at the same level as Joe's pizza! JUST LOOK AG MY PICTURES! Seriously dude! The pizza has fresh mozzarella cheese! Spicy crispy pepperoni! Th ... read more
Kevin H via google.com - Apr 16, 2021
We just got into town and walked to Times Square and we were very hungry. Ran into this lil pizza pl
We just got into town and walked to Times Square and we were very hungry. Ran into this lil pizza place and all the pizza looked so good. The staff was super friendly and the pepperoni was great. My wife got the Margarita pizza slice and it was on point. I recommend it if you want a quick meal.
HJ379 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 16, 2021
NOT A FAKE REVIEW: THIS PLACE IS FREAKING AMAZING!!! As God is my witness! Everyone must come and tr
NOT A FAKE REVIEW: THIS PLACE IS FREAKING AMAZING!!! As God is my witness! Everyone must come and try their pizza! I have eaten a lot of pizza in NYC just check my reviews! This place I put at the same level as Joe's pizza! JUST LOOK AG MY PICTURES! Seriously dude! The pizza has fresh mozzarella cheese! Spicy crispy pepperoni! The po ... read more
Kevin H. via yelp.com - Apr 16, 2021
Stumbled upon this place while heading back to our hotel. What a treat that was, the pizza was crispy and cheesy at the same time! They had so many single slice types of pizza to choose from and they all looked so good it was hard to choose!
Jennifer Martin via google.com - Mar 29, 2021
Very tasty pizza and friendly staff!
Dima via google.com - Mar 29, 2021
Good pizza ... read more
Juan busanet via google.com - Mar 26, 2021
Amazing new place, will visit whenever i'm in NYC! The pizza is amazing especially the margarita and pepperoni slices! Clean and friendly staff. Will be back ... read more
Jessica K via google.com - Mar 26, 2021
Got a Margherita and a Red slice, both were delicious with a crispy crust and delicious sauce and toppings. The staff were friendly and the shop is kept very clean. One of my new favorite pizza places! I'll definitely be back.
Jonathan Zisser via google.com - Mar 26, 2021
Amazing new place, will visit whenever i'm in NYC! The pizza is amazing especially the margarita and
Amazing new place, will visit whenever i'm in NYC! The pizza is amazing especially the margarita and pepperoni slices! Clean and friendly staff. Will be back!
Jess K. via yelp.com - Mar 25, 2021
Never have I ever enjoyed such a ridiculous volume of greasy pepperoni on a thick crust. Enjoy this stop...steps from the Aladdin theater.
Brandon Klingensmith via google.com - Mar 19, 2021
The Margarita and Mushroom & Spinach pizza were tasty. The place was clean and servers were nice.
Leonardo Torres via google.com - Mar 12, 2021
Delicious traditional NY pizza . Go here! Run by an amazing family and pizza is delicious!!!
Mel Peters via google.com - Mar 5, 2021
This place is amazing, it refreshing to see such great place in the city, been going here for couple of weeks now, pizza is amazing, place is super clean and the staff is very friendly. Highly recommend!!
Valdrin Ademaj via google.com - Mar 5, 2021
Good pizza ... read more
Tommy Modula via google.com - Jan 2, 2021
First time in New York and the best Pizza! Freshly hand made!
Leo Dagne via google.com - Jan 2, 2021
Great pizza with a wonderful sauce although not as hot as you would hope on arrival. The garlic knot
Great pizza with a wonderful sauce although not as hot as you would hope on arrival. The garlic knots were a little dry but the garlic and basil on them saved it. I would order from here again because that pizza sauce was tasty!
Jillian T. via yelp.com - Dec 22, 2020
Great new slice shop. Super clean and fresh. Friendly staff and really nice owner. See photos for the quality of this place ... read more
Jeff Gebott via google.com - Dec 2, 2020
I HAVEN'T LEFT MY HOUSE IN 3 MONTHS BUT WHEN I HEARD ABOUT THIS PLACE I HAD TO GET OUT OF HIDING. HANDS DOWN THE BEST PIZZA IN THE CITY TOTALLY WORTH IT. ALSO NICEST/CLEANEST PIZZERIA I'VE EVER BEEN TOO ... read more
Brandon Rubinshtein via google.com - Dec 2, 2020
Pizza is great Keep the place clean and sanitized ... read more
MYX STUDIOS via google.com - Dec 2, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire